How to Figure Out Your Real Cost Per Order
A step-by-step method for calculating fully loaded fulfillment cost per order, with the inputs founders usually skip.
When founders ask us if our pricing is competitive, the honest answer is that it depends on a number most of them haven't calculated yet: fully loaded cost per order. Here's how to get it.
Start with the per-order line items
- Pick and pack fee (including any per-additional-item charge).
- Outbound postage, averaged across your actual zone mix.
- Packaging materials that leave the building with the order.
- Inserts, stickers, or gift notes if you use them.
Then allocate the monthly costs
Storage, account fees, and software subscriptions aren't per-order costs, but they still hit every order. Take your monthly total, divide by monthly orders, and add it. This is the step almost everyone skips, and it's usually where the surprise lives — at low volume, a $300 monthly storage bill on 150 orders adds $2 per order.
Add a returns allowance
If 8% of orders come back and each return costs you roughly a fulfillment cycle plus partial product loss, that's a real per-order number. Estimate it, don't ignore it.
Returns eating your margin? Here's how to build a policy that doesn't.
Read the Returns GuideWorked example
- Pick and pack: $2.00
- Postage (2.1 lb average, mixed zones): $8.40
- Box and dunnage: $0.85
- Storage and fees allocated over 400 orders: $0.95
- Returns allowance at 8%: $0.90
- Fully loaded cost per order: $13.10
If you were quoting yourself $2 plus postage, you were off by about 25%. That gap is the difference between a healthy brand and one that runs out of cash while growing.
What to do with the number
Compare it against your average order value. If fulfillment is more than about 15–20% of AOV, you have three levers: reduce package size, raise AOV through bundling, or charge for shipping. Switching 3PLs to save 20 cents on a pick fee won't fix a structural problem.
Run your numbers against ours in about a minute.
Estimate Your CostsWant to see what your store would actually save?
Get a free, no-pressure estimate in 30 seconds. No call required.