Operations••6 min read

    Shipping Insurance: When It's Worth It and When It Isn't

    A clear-eyed look at when shipping insurance pays for itself, and the claims process realities nobody puts in the brochure.

    Every founder eventually asks whether to insure packages. The answer depends less on fear and more on three numbers: your product value, your loss rate, and your tolerance for claims paperwork.

    The math, plainly

    Carrier insurance typically costs around $1 per $100 of declared value, with a minimum around $2–3 per package. If your average order value is $40, insuring every package at $3 means you're spending 7.5% of order value to protect against a loss rate that's usually well under 1%. Unless your product is high-value or fragile, blanket insurance is a bad trade.

    When insurance makes sense

    • High average order value — jewelry, electronics, anything over roughly $200.
    • Fragile goods where 'arrives damaged' is a real, recurring category.
    • Destinations with a documented pattern of theft or loss.

    In those cases, insure by rule — value threshold or destination — not by mood.

    The claims reality

    Claims take weeks. Carriers ask for proof of value, packaging photos, and sometimes the destroyed item. Payouts are not guaranteed. If your plan is 'file a claim and get made whole,' test that plan once before you depend on it. Some brands self-insure simply because their own refund process is faster and cheaper than the claim process, even when they'd eventually win the claim.

    What actually reduces losses

    1. Correct addressing at checkout — a huge share of 'lost' packages are address errors.
    2. Right-sized packaging — small boxes get crushed less than items rattling in big ones.
    3. Photo-on-delivery services where available for high-value shipments.
    4. A clear replacement policy so support can act the day a customer reports a problem, not after the claim resolves.

    Right-sizing your packaging helps more than insurance. Here's the guide.

    Read the Packaging Guide

    The honest recommendation

    For most D2C brands under $150 AOV: don't insure by default, do track your loss rate, and do have a fast replacement policy. Paying $3 to protect a $40 order against a 0.5% risk isn't prudence — it's a subscription to anxiety. Save the insurance budget for the SKUs where the math actually works.

    Questions about how we handle lost packages? Ask a real person.

    Talk to Us

    Want to see what your store would actually save?

    Get a free, no-pressure estimate in 30 seconds. No call required.